0073 — A symbol that is not trading has no market context
Status: Accepted Edited 2026-11-15 to remove deployment details. Date: 2026-11-14 Amends: ADR-0072 (what counts as a symbol whose context can be read)
Context and Problem Statement
Section titled “Context and Problem Statement”ADR-0072 makes the context from a symbol’s newest bars and answers {symbol, error} only when
they cannot be read. Binance, though, still serves the klines of a symbol it delisted from spot.
XMRUSDT was delisted in 2024, and its last 1d candle closed at 118.70 on 2024-02-20. In production,
get_market_context answered:
XMRUSDT 118.7 | trend 4h down, 1d down | funding 0.1382% | F&G 13 extreme fearThat puts a 2024 price and 2024 trends next to a live funding rate and today’s index, with nothing
to say so. The same holds for any delisted or halted symbol, and a wake-up’s context would carry it
too. A caller that already drops coins not trading on Binance spot avoids this, but the context must
not depend on that.
Decision Drivers
Section titled “Decision Drivers”- A context describes the market now. A price from long ago must not read as a current one.
- No new data source and no extra request: decide from the bars the context reads anyway.
- No false alarm on a market that is shut for a weekend or a holiday.
Considered Options
Section titled “Considered Options”- The age of the newest bar, with a limit per kind of market (chosen).
- Binance’s exchange information (the symbol’s
status, e.g.TRADING). An extra request, and there is nothing like it for Yahoo. - The 24h ticker’s
closeTimeand trade count. Another request, and Binance only.
Decision Outcome
Section titled “Decision Outcome”A symbol is not trading when the newest 4h bar of its context’s read is older than:
- 8 hours since it opened, for a Binance symbol, which trades around the clock. The forming 4h bar opened at most 4 hours ago; one bar more is allowed for a late feed. Older means nothing traded for at least one whole bar.
- 7 days, for any other symbol (stocks, ETFs, indices, FX through Yahoo), whose market shuts for weekends and holidays. A weekend with a holiday after it stays within that.
Such a symbol answers {"symbol": "XMRUSDT", "error": "no bar since 2024-02-20T00:00:00Z: not trading"} with no price, trend or futures parts. The error is held for a minute like any other
answer. A wake-up about it goes without context, as for any context that could not be read.
Consequences
Section titled “Consequences”- Good: a delisted or halted symbol no longer shows an old price as the current one, in the tool or in a wake-up.
- Good: no request is added; the check reads the bars already fetched.
- Neutral: a symbol read from Yahoo that trades around the clock (BTC-USD) gets the lenient 7-day limit.
- Out of scope:
get_quoteshas the same blind spot (XMRUSDT answerslast118.7, change 0). Its ticker carries acloseTimethat could tell, but a limit there changes what the web watchlist shows for illiquid pairs, so it is a decision of its own.generate_chartdraws old candles with their dates on the axis, which says what they are.
Validation
Section titled “Validation”- A test symbol under the test source whose bars end on 2024-02-20 answers the error; with the check disabled the test fails.
- The two limits are tested on both sides: a Binance bar 8 and 9 hours old, a stock’s 4 and 8 days.
- A live call on the branch answers XMRUSDT with
no bar since 2024-02-20T00:00:00Z: not trading, and BTCUSDT with its context as before.